A Doctor’s Perspective on Asthma, Air Quality, and Our Homes
On the Air Quality Matters podcast, we often discuss the links between the buildings we inhabit and our health. One of the most frequent and concerning outcomes we touch upon is asthma, particularly in children. But in focusing on the broad statistics and environmental causes, it’s easy to lose sight of the visceral reality of what it means for a child to struggle for breath, and for a family to face that crisis.
In a recent episode, I shared a memory from my early career as a paramedic—a late-night call to a child in the midst of a severe asthma attack. The image of the child’s struggle and the father’s utter helplessness, having run out of tools to fix the situation, has stayed with me for decades. It’s a stark reminder that what we discuss in technical terms can be a matter of life and death at the human level.
This experience set the stage for a crucial conversation with Abigail Whitehouse , a Senior Clinical Lecturer in Children's Environmental Health and an honorary paediatric respiratory consultant. We moved beyond the generalities to have a frank discussion about childhood asthma: what it is, how a crisis unfolds, and the complex web of factors that cause and trigger it.
The Anatomy of an Asthma Attack
What was happening to that young boy I encountered all those years ago? Dr. Whitehouse walked us through the physiology of a life-threatening asthma attack with powerful clarity. We discussed the cascade of events inside the body: the inflamed airways, already sensitive due to the underlying condition, are exposed to a trigger. This causes the airways to tighten and fill with immune cells, making it progressively harder to breathe.
One of the most insightful points Dr. Whitehouse made is that the primary difficulty in an asthma attack isn't getting air in, but blowing it back out against constricted airways. This explains the distinctive "tripod" posture a child in distress adopts—leaning forward, hands on knees—in a desperate attempt to force their airways open. In the full episode, she explains the critical point at which home reliever inhalers stop working and why, in that moment, the only correct action is an immediate trip to the hospital. Hearing her describe the emergency tools available in A&E, from oxygen-driven nebulisers to IV medications, underscores the severity of the situation and the thin line these children walk.
From Healthy Child to Chronic Condition: The Environmental Connection
How does a child develop asthma in the first place? We explored the complex origins of the condition, moving beyond the acute crisis to understand the chronic picture. Dr. Whitehouse explained that while there is a genetic predisposition, asthma is fundamentally an environmental disease. She described the concept of an "immune switch," a pivotal moment often triggered by a viral infection (like RSV) or environmental exposures during critical periods of lung development.
This is where the conversation becomes vital for everyone in the built environment sector. We discussed the role of various environmental factors in both causing the initial "switch" and triggering subsequent attacks. These include:
Air Pollution: The established links between outdoor pollutants like particulate matter and nitrogen dioxide and the onset and exacerbation of asthma.
Housing Conditions: The complex and often debated role of damp and mould, and how poor housing is intertwined with fuel poverty and social inequality, creating a perfect storm of risk factors.
The conversation highlighted a profound concept: a child’s early-life environmental exposures can effectively set a "glass ceiling" on their peak lung function. Poor air quality during childhood doesn't just trigger symptoms; it can permanently limit their respiratory capacity, predisposing them to serious conditions like COPD later in life. Understanding the nuance of these interconnected risks, as discussed in the podcast, is essential for anyone involved in creating healthier living spaces.
Towards Prevention: A Systemic Challenge and a Glimmer of Hope
One of the most challenging takeaways from our discussion was the systemic nature of the problem. In the UK, we have some of the highest rates of childhood asthma deaths, often linked to poor housing and pollution exposure. Abi spoke candidly about the gaps in traditional medical training, where taking a detailed "housing history" is not yet standard practice, despite its clear importance for respiratory health.
However, the conversation also offered a powerful sense of hope. Abi is at the forefront of a shift towards prevention. Her work with the innovative Children's Environmental Health Service at the Royal London Hospital aims to bridge this gap. By combining clinical care with in-depth environmental investigation—including personal pollution monitoring and home assessments—her team is moving beyond simply prescribing medication. The goal, as she passionately articulated, is a "symptom-free life" for children with asthma. Hearing her describe how this holistic approach empowers families with knowledge and agency is a compelling blueprint for the future of healthcare.
One Take: Does Passivhaus Deliver on its IAQ Promise?
Following on from our deep dive into a specific health outcome, the latest One Take episode examines a potential solution: the Passivhaus standard. We often champion Passivhaus for its energy efficiency, but does it truly deliver on the promise of superior indoor air quality (IAQ)?
I reviewed a comprehensive paper by Gabriel Rojas and colleagues, which synthesised data from over 600 Passivhaus homes. The findings are a lesson in nuance. The good news? Certified Passivhaus homes generally show lower levels of CO2, VOCs, and radon than conventional homes, thanks to their continuous mechanical ventilation (MVHR) systems.
The critical caveat, however, is quality control. The review highlighted a UK meta-study with a startling statistic: while 100% of certified Passivhaus dwellings met required ventilation airflows, only 47% of other, non-certified homes with MVHR did. This reveals a systemic failure in the wider industry, where systems are installed but not properly commissioned.
The paper also identified a major blind spot: particulate matter from cooking. In highly airtight homes, using recirculating cooker hoods (a common energy-saving choice) can lead to dangerous spikes in PM2.5, as these fine particles are simply pumped back into the living space. The episode details why the standard MVHR extract grille isn't a substitute and discusses the new Passivhaus Institute guidance that now strongly recommends externally vented extraction.
The verdict? Passivhaus can deliver excellent IAQ, but its success hinges entirely on rigorous quality assurance and a holistic approach that accounts for all pollution sources, especially the cooker.
The Air Quality Matters Podcast in Partnership with
Farmwood - Eurovent- Aico - Aereco - Ultra Protect -
The One Take Podcast in Partnership with
SafeTraces and Inbiot
Do check them out in the links and on the Air Quality Matters Website.
If you haven't checked out the YouTube channel its here. Do subscribe if you can, lots more content is coming soon.